Customizing REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME is cumbersome

[Meiyer]

When a custom REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME is defined (for example, for the LoginView in urls.py), the two views PasswordChangeView and PasswordChangeDoneView will still use the built-in name next. This is due to the decorator django.contrib.auth.decorators.login_required which uses the name from django.contrib.auth.REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME and is not customizable.

[Tim Graham]

As far as I see, the problem isn't specific to the password change views. If you customize LoginView.redirect_field_name, then you need to update all views decorated with login_required() to use @login_required(redirect_field_name='...'). The problem is that you can't make this change in views in third-party apps. For that reason, I wonder if it would have been better to make REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME customization use a setting (as originally proposed in #5394) rather than an argument.

[Meiyer]

Currently, in order to make Django (by itself, without 3rd-party apps!) work as expected with a customized REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME, one has to:

1. subclass LoginView (or provide a value in urls.py via LoginView.as_view())
2. subclass LogoutView (or provide a value in urls.py via LogoutView.as_view())
3. subclass LoginRequiredMixin
4. subclass PermissionRequiredMixin
5. subclass UserPassesTestMixin
6. subclass any view that uses the login_required decorator, that is, PasswordChangeView, PasswordChangeDoneView
   • if a custom view uses the decorator, one has to remember to modify it as well
7. subclass any view that uses the user_passes_test decorator (currently only in Admin)
   • if a custom view uses the decorator, one has to remember to modify it as well
8. build own special treatment of redirection for flat pages that require registration (no subclassing is possible)

This does not make sense.

[Tim Graham]

Perhaps it's worth making a proposal on the DevelopersMailingList. It would be interesting to research if this feature is used to solve a different use case or if it's mostly unused such that this issue hasn't come up before.

[Mateusz Kurowski]

Here is a monkey patch i am using.
In the apps.py ready method.

 def ready(self):
        from django.conf import settings
        from django.contrib import auth
        auth.REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME = settings.REDIRECT_FIELD_NAME

I think its good for the security to allow this customization. It's always good to make identification of the framework running website harder.