AlterModelOptions should check for changes

[no]

Consider the following model:

PERM_DEFS = {
   ('perm1', 'Desc1') : 123,
   ('perm2', 'Desc2') : 321
}
class Spam(models.Model):
    class Meta:
        permissions = list(PERM_DEFS.keys())

Currently, running makemigrations will always generate a new migration even though the permissions list doesn't change. Perhaps the inspector could do a set(old_attr) == set(new_attr) type operation on list style attributes such as permissions and default_permissions.

Current workaround is: permissions = list(sorted(PERM_DEFS.keys()))

[Baptiste Mispelon]

Hi,

This actually depends on your Python version.
On Python 3.3 and later, the order of dictionaries will change between different runs (that feature is called "hash randomization" if you want to look deeper).

On earlier versions of Python though, that order is consistent so the autodetector doesn't see any changes and no new migrations are created.

I'm not sure if this warrants the additional code complexity.
If you need a consistent order here you could use an OrderedDict or user permissions = sorted(PERM_DEFS.keys()).

[no]

I don't think there's that much extra complexity: one possible solution: ​https://github.com/django/django/pull/3356

[Tim Graham]

I don't think there's a good reason to say the ordering of permissions isn't important. For example, you might have a migration that indexes the permissions tuple to get a particular permission. Using sorted() as Baptiste suggested seems like the best solution to me.